How to Find a Babysitter You Trust: Interview Questions, Safety Checks and a Parent Handoff Checklist

Babysitter caring for a toddler and baby while playing together at home

Originally published May 24, 2026. Last updated August 19, 2026.

Leaving your child with a new babysitter can feel like a surprisingly big milestone.

You may be excited to have an evening out, grateful for some help, and still find yourself wondering: Will they know what to do if something happens? Will they follow our routines? Will my child feel comfortable with them?

Those are reasonable questions.

Finding a babysitter you feel comfortable with does not require finding someone who does everything exactly the way you do. It is about choosing someone who is responsible, communicates well, understands your child’s needs and knows when to ask for help.

And once you find that person, a clear handoff can make everyone feel more prepared.

Here is what to look for, what to ask and what your babysitter should know before you walk out the door.

1. Start With Recommendations, Then Check References

Recommendations from people you know can be a helpful place to begin.

Ask friends, neighbours, relatives, parents from school or daycare, and other trusted families:

  • Who have you used?

  • Were they dependable?

  • How were they with your children?

  • Did they follow instructions?

  • How did they communicate with you?

  • Would you hire them again?

A personal recommendation is useful, but it should not replace your own conversation with the sitter.

Every family is different, and someone who is a wonderful fit for one child may not automatically be the right fit for yours.

If you are considering someone you do not already know well, ask for one or two recent references.

Helpful questions for a reference include:

  • How long did they babysit for your family?

  • What ages were your children at the time?

  • Were they reliable and punctual?

  • How did they handle difficult or unexpected situations?

  • Did they communicate concerns appropriately?

  • Did they follow your family’s rules and routines?

  • Would you hire them again?

References are one piece of the picture. Combine them with your own interview, observations and expectations.

2. Look at Experience, Training and Readiness

There is no single qualification that makes someone the β€œperfect” babysitter.

Instead, think about what your particular child needs.

A sitter caring for a sleeping eight-year-old for a few hours may need a different level of experience than someone caring for a four-month-old who needs bottles, diaper changes and bedtime.

Depending on your family, you may want to ask about:

  • Experience caring for children close to your child’s age

  • Infant and child CPR training

  • First aid training or certification

  • Babysitting-course completion

  • Experience preparing bottles or feeding babies

  • Familiarity with choking prevention and choking first aid

  • Safe-sleep knowledge

  • Experience with food allergies or medical needs

  • Experience supporting children with disabilities or additional needs

  • Comfort managing more than one child

  • Experience with bedtime routines, toileting or behavioural challenges

The Canadian Red Cross Babysitting course is one example of training designed specifically for young babysitters. It covers caregiving skills, developmental stages, safety, decision-making and basic first aid.

CPR and first aid training are separate considerations. If current certification is important to your family, ask what training was completed, through which organization and when.

You do not need to turn the conversation into a job interview at a boardroom table. A few thoughtful questions can tell you a lot.

3. Ask Scenario Questions, Not Just Yes-or-No Questions

Instead of only asking:

β€œAre you comfortable with choking?”

try:

β€œWhat would you do if my toddler suddenly could not cough, cry or make a sound while eating?”

Instead of:

β€œDo you know about safe sleep?”

ask:

β€œIf the baby falls asleep somewhere other than the crib, what would you do?”

Scenario questions help you understand how someone thinks and whether their knowledge matches your family’s expectations.

Other useful examples include:

  • What would you do if my child fell and hit their head?

  • When would you call 911?

  • What would you do if you could not reach me?

  • What would you do if the smoke alarm went off?

  • How would you respond if my toddler had a tantrum?

  • What would you do if the baby would not stop crying?

  • What would you do if someone came to the door?

  • What would you do if my child asked to do something I had already said no to?

  • What would you do if you noticed signs of an allergic reaction?

  • What would you do if siblings started fighting?

You are not looking for rehearsed perfection.

You are looking for good judgement, willingness to follow instructions and someone who is comfortable saying, β€œI’m not sure. What would you like me to do?”

That is often a much better answer than pretending to know.

4. Talk About Your Family’s Non-Negotiables

A sitter does not need to parent exactly like you.

They do need to understand the boundaries that matter while your child is in their care.

Talk through things such as:

  • Bedtime routines

  • Screen-time expectations

  • Discipline and behaviour guidance

  • Foods that may or may not be served

  • Whether the sitter may prepare food

  • Bathing rules

  • Outdoor play

  • Whether your child may leave the house

  • Visitors

  • Photos and social media

  • Answering the door

  • Transportation

  • Pets

  • Baby-monitor use

  • How often you would like updates

Be specific about anything that is particularly important to your family.

For example:

β€œPlease do not post or send photos of the kids.”

β€œNo one else should come into the house while we are gone.”

β€œIf you take them outside, please stay in the backyard.”

β€œPlease text us after the baby is asleep.”

Clear expectations are easier to follow than assumptions.

5. Make Sure Infant Safety Instructions Are Specific

If your babysitter will be caring for a baby, spend extra time going through feeding and sleep routines.

Safe Sleep

Show the sitter exactly where your baby sleeps and explain your usual safe-sleep setup.

Health Canada recommends placing babies on their back for every sleep in a crib, cradle or bassinet that meets current Canadian safety regulations, using a firm, flat sleep surface that is free of pillows, loose blankets, bumper pads, stuffed toys and other soft items.

A baby who falls asleep in a swing, bouncer, stroller, car seat or other seated product should be moved to an appropriate sleep space when possible.

Do not assume another caregiver has received the same safe-sleep information you have.

Show them.

Feeding and Choking Prevention

If your baby or toddler will eat while you are away, explain exactly what they may be served and how it should be prepared.

Infants and young children should be seated upright and supervised while eating.

Show the sitter:

  • Which foods are appropriate

  • How foods should be cut or prepared

  • Which foods you do not serve

  • Where bottles, formula or breastmilk are stored

  • How bottles should be prepared or warmed

  • Any feeding equipment they will need

  • What choking first aid training they have received

Avoid leaving unfamiliar food preparation decisions for the sitter if you can prepare things ahead of time.

A labelled meal or snack can make the evening easier for everyone.

6. Make an Allergy and Medication Plan

If your child has an allergy, asthma, seizure disorder, diabetes or another medical condition, a quick verbal explanation as you put your shoes on is not enough.

Leave clear written instructions.

For a child with a food allergy, this may include:

  • The allergen or allergens

  • Foods that are safe

  • How to reduce cross-contact

  • Signs of an allergic reaction

  • Your child’s Anaphylaxis Action Plan

  • Where epinephrine auto-injectors are kept

  • When and how they should be used

  • What to do after epinephrine is given

Food Allergy Canada specifically recommends reviewing a child’s Anaphylaxis Action Plan with caregivers and practising how to use an epinephrine auto-injector.

For medications, leave the name, dose, timing and instructions in writing and make sure the sitter is comfortable following them.

If your child has more complex medical needs, confirm that the sitter has the knowledge and training required to follow their individual care plan.

7. Start With a Trial Visit

Your first babysitting experience does not have to begin with a six-hour evening away.

A shorter introduction can help everyone become more comfortable.

You might try:

  • Having the sitter visit while you are still home

  • Asking them to play with your child while you prepare dinner

  • Going for a short walk nearby

  • Booking a brief daytime visit

  • Having them help with part of the bedtime routine before the first solo evening

Watch how they interact naturally.

Do they:

  • Get down to your child’s level?

  • Speak respectfully?

  • Stay attentive?

  • Put their phone away?

  • Respond patiently to crying or frustration?

  • Follow your instructions?

  • Ask questions when they are unsure?

  • Respect your child’s boundaries?

  • Seem comfortable with the responsibilities you are giving them?

Also notice how your child responds.

A child does not need to immediately adore someone new. Some children take time to warm up.

What matters more is whether the interaction appears respectful, patient and appropriate.

8. Before You Leave: The Babysitter Handoff Checklist

This is the part I would encourage every family to do, even with a sitter they already know well.

Do not make your babysitter search through your phone contacts or kitchen cupboards during an emergency.

Leave the important information somewhere obvious.

The Government of Canada also offers a family emergency-plan template that can help you organize contacts, medical information and household emergency details.

Emergency Information

Give your babysitter:

  • Your full home address, including unit number if applicable

  • Both parents’ or guardians’ phone numbers

  • A second trusted adult they can contact if you cannot be reached

  • 911 for emergencies

  • Your provincial or territorial Poison Centre information

  • Any important health-care contact information

  • Your expected location and approximate return time

Your exact address matters.

In an emergency, a sitter may be nervous or unfamiliar with your neighbourhood. Having the address written clearly gives them something to read directly to a 911 dispatcher.

Make one expectation especially clear:

If there is a life-threatening emergency, call 911 first. Then contact us as soon as possible.

Medical Information

Leave written information about:

  • Allergies

  • Medical conditions

  • Medications

  • Epinephrine or other emergency medication

  • Relevant medical devices

  • Any individualized emergency plan

Show the sitter where everything is located before you leave.

Food and Feeding

Review:

  • What your child may eat

  • What they should not eat

  • Choking hazards to avoid

  • Food preparation instructions

  • Bottle preparation and storage if applicable

  • Where bibs, cups and feeding supplies are kept

For younger children, remind the sitter that eating should happen seated and supervised.

Sleep

For babies, review:

  • Where baby sleeps

  • Sleepwear or sleep sack

  • Baby-monitor instructions

  • Usual bedtime routine

  • Safe-sleep setup

Keep instructions simple enough that there is no guesswork.

Around the House

Show them:

  • First aid kit

  • Fire exits

  • Smoke and carbon monoxide alarms

  • Fire extinguisher

  • Flashlights

  • Alarm system instructions

  • Door locks

  • Pet supplies if needed

Tell them whether anyone is expected to arrive at the house.

Your Child’s Routine

Write down the basics:

  • Meals and snacks

  • Nap or bedtime

  • Toileting or diaper routine

  • Favourite comfort items

  • Usual soothing techniques

  • Screen rules

  • Activities they enjoy

  • Anything likely to make the evening easier

This does not need to become a six-page operating manual.

One clear sheet on the counter can be enough.

9. Match the Babysitter to Your Child’s Stage

Different ages bring different responsibilities.

Babies

Look for comfort with:

  • Safe sleep

  • Bottle or infant feeding

  • Diapering

  • Soothing

  • Infant choking first aid

  • Infant CPR

  • Recognizing when something is not normal

Toddlers and Preschoolers

Look for:

  • Close supervision

  • Choking awareness

  • Patience with big emotions

  • Safe redirection

  • Comfort with toileting or diapers

  • Awareness of climbing, water and household hazards

  • Ability to maintain routines and boundaries

School-Aged Children

Discuss:

  • Technology rules

  • Snacks and cooking

  • Outdoor boundaries

  • Friends or visitors

  • Answering doors and phones

  • Sibling disagreements

  • Homework and bedtime expectations

Children With Additional Needs

Tell your sitter what helps your child succeed.

That might include:

  • Communication preferences

  • Sensory needs

  • Mobility needs

  • Medical equipment

  • Behavioural supports

  • Toileting support

  • Wandering or elopement concerns

  • Seizure or allergy plans

  • Calming strategies

  • Important routines

A good sitter should not be expected to guess.

The more clearly you share what works for your child, the better prepared they can be.

10. After the First Babysitting Visit

When you get home, check in.

Ask the sitter:

  • How did the evening go?

  • Did anything unexpected happen?

  • Was anything difficult?

  • Did my child eat or drink?

  • How did bedtime go?

  • Is there anything you need to know before next time?

And when appropriate, ask your child too.

Keep it simple and neutral:

β€œHow was your night?”

β€œWhat did you guys do?”

β€œWhat was your favourite part?”

β€œWas there anything you didn’t like?”

You are gathering information, not searching for a perfect report card.

One slightly messy bedtime or a child who missed their usual snack does not necessarily mean someone is a poor babysitter.

Look at the bigger picture:

Was your child cared for safely?

Were your instructions respected?

Did the sitter communicate appropriately?

Would you feel comfortable inviting them back?

A Quick Babysitter Interview Checklist

Before hiring a new sitter, consider asking:

  • What ages have you cared for before?

  • What do you enjoy most about babysitting?

  • Have you taken a babysitting course?

  • Do you have current first aid or CPR training?

  • How would you respond if a child were choking?

  • When would you call 911?

  • How do you handle tantrums or children who refuse to cooperate?

  • What would you do if you could not reach me?

  • Are you comfortable following our safe-sleep and feeding instructions?

  • Are you comfortable caring for my child’s allergies or medical needs?

  • Are you comfortable with our house rules?

  • May I contact a recent reference?

You do not need every sitter to check every possible box.

You do need someone whose experience, maturity and preparation match the responsibility you are asking them to take on.

Final Thoughts

Finding a babysitter you trust can take a little time, and that is okay.

The goal is not to eliminate every possible worry before you leave the house.

The goal is to choose thoughtfully, communicate clearly and make sure the person caring for your child has the information they need to handle both the ordinary moments and the unexpected ones.

Check references.

Ask good questions.

Walk through your routines.

Leave emergency information where it is easy to find.

And give everyone a little time to get comfortable with each other.

A good babysitter can become a wonderful part of your family’s support system.

And knowing that they understand your child, your expectations and your safety plan can make walking out that door feel a whole lot easier.

You’ve got this!

Continue Learning

Continue building your family’s safety toolkit with these trusted resources from Bump + Baby Matters.

Infant & Child CPR + Choking Classes

Infant Choking First Aid: The 5 + 5 Rule Explained

Unexpected Choking Hazards Parents Often Overlook (And How to Spot Them)

What to Do If Your Baby Has an Allergic Reaction: A Step-by-Step Guide for Parents

Your Family Safety Plan: A Step-by-Step Guide to Feeling Prepared, Not Panicked

Have a question? We're always happy to help. Send us a message on Instagram.

Previous
Previous

How to Talk to Kids About CPR and 911 (By Age): Building Confidence Without Fear

Next
Next

What to Do If Your Baby Has an Allergic Reaction